Social Position and Fairness Views

Authors : Kristoffer Hvidberg, Claus Kreiner, and Stefanie Stantcheva

Publication: NBER Working Paper 28099, 2020

Abstract:

How well do people know their social position relative to others in society and how does their position shape their views on the fairness of unequal outcomes? We provide new answers to these long-standing questions by combining survey-elicited perceptions on income positions and fairness views for a large, representative sample of prime-age people in Denmark with administrative data on their actual income positions, income histories, life events, and reference groups. This enables us to compare the income and perceived income positions reported by the respondents (in the survey) to the actual numbers (obtained from their tax returns) and to study social positions relative to many reference groups. These groups are others from the same cohort, co-workers in the same firm or sector, former schoolmates, neighbors or people living in the same municipality, or people with same education levels. We also show how changes in social position affect fairness views by exploiting the past changes in social positions of respondents, quasi- experimental real-life events (unemployment, health shocks, or promotions) that shift social positions, as well as randomized information treatments that show people their actual social positions. Our three main findings are: First, people underestimate the degree of inequality by believing that others are closer to themselves than they really are, yet misperceptions are not that large. Second, fairness views on inequality covary strongly — and more than political views — with the current social positions of individuals. Multiple pieces of evidence point to a causal relationship. Third, people view inequality within their education group and within co-workers to be most unfair, but in these same dimensions people underestimate the degree of inequality most and lower-income people strongly overestimate their own positions.